Shopping Basket
Your Basket is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should receive an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Basket

Portland Leadership Institute

Nourish the Leader Within You

Leadership for the 21st Century


Alex Rodriguez and Arbitration

Posted on 19 August, 2013 at 2:35
All right, let's get this straight, let's come clean.
  • I've been a Yankee fan all my life.  I live and breathe Yankees.
  • And Alex Rodriguez (ARod) is a cheat.  But at least he's my cheat.  In the same way that Barry Bonds belonged to Giants fans, Mark McGwyre to his fans, Roger Clemens and Ryan Braun to others, etc. 

Today we get to talk two topics:  arbitration and due process.  A sense of ethics and morality does not matter.  All that matters is one person's reading of the contract.

(to all sports announcers:  it is an arbitrator, NOT an arbiter, who will decide this.  An arbiter can settle disputes, but legally it is an arbitrator who will settle this one.  Hearing the word "arbiter" used gives an indication of the quality of the information being discussed.  Most announcers do not get this right.)

Most of you know the story.  Alex Rodriguez has been accused of using performance enhancing drugs (PEDs).  The current collective bargaining agreement (CBA) for Major League Baseball (MLB) prohibits this through a Joint Drug Prevention Agreement (  The CBA/JDA states the penalty:  a 50 game suspension for a first time offender, with the right to appeal.  As in many CBAs, the employee is permitted to work (play baseball in this case) while the appeal is being heard.  That's due process.

ARod is a pariah; he is alleged to have purchased PEDs from Biogenesis, to have recruited other players to use Biogenesis, to have lied to MLB investigators, to have attempted to purchase and hide evidence as part of a coverup, to have snitched on teammates, and to have committed other similar atrocities.  People are upset over the size of his contract; they are clamoring for his expulsion from baseball.  While most other offenders in the Biogenesis case have been given and accepted 50 game suspensions, ARod was suspended for 211 games.  He has understandably appealed.

Let's explain arbitration.  The arbitrator is jointly selected by the two parties, based on their knowledge of the arbitrator's past record.  Arbitrators make decisions based on three factors:  the facts of the case, the relevant contract provisions, and the law.  Nothing else.  Common sense does not matter.  Letters to the editor are irrelevant.  A sense of fairness is not a factor.  The facts, the contract, and the law.  Period.

The CBA and the JDA are specific:  a first time offender receives a 50 game suspension.  If multiple offenses occur simultaneously, the largest possible penalty takes precedence; simultaneous offenses are not cumulative. 

Other than the use of PEDs, none of the list of alleged offenses is identified in the CBA.  No matter how anyone feels about these, they can not factor into the arbitrator's decision.  In the eyes of the arbitrator, they do not exist.

And a positive 2003 test:  this predated the current CBA.  It is excluded.  From the arbitrator's perspective, it did not happen.

You don't have to like this, but the arbitrator has only one option.  Follow the contract provisions and reduce the suspension to 50 games.  This is an open and shut case. 

If you were an employee and your manager punished you more severely than permitted, you would want similar protections and due process. 

Categories: Leadership Musings

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply Ivyproni
3:55 on 4 June, 2022 
generic zoloft online motilium domperidone 10mg
Reply Ugoproni
6:58 on 4 June, 2022 
cialis 5mg online
Reply Janeproni
17:53 on 4 June, 2022 
buy ciprofloxacin 500mg online uk
Reply Ivyproni
18:06 on 4 June, 2022 
buy inderal trazodone brand name augmentin 625 us buying accutane online buy albuterol pills propranolol online uk albendazole brand name india augmentin tablets 625mg
Reply Markproni
18:57 on 4 June, 2022 
price of propranolol in us
Reply Booproni
0:26 on 5 June, 2022 
albendazole 400g citalopram 60 mg accutane online for sale
Reply Markproni
0:53 on 6 June, 2022 
clonidine for sleep
Reply Wimproni
10:46 on 6 June, 2022 
zovirax tablets otc
Reply Janeproni
16:00 on 6 June, 2022 
canadian purchase propecia
Reply Sueproni
1:47 on 7 June, 2022 
albenza cost us drug celebrex vermox usa buy
Reply Maryproni
4:24 on 7 June, 2022 
lisinopril 15 mg motilium canada otc buy cephalexin online without prescription
Reply Ashproni
6:51 on 7 June, 2022 
suhagra 50 mg price in india nexium over the counter canada phenergan capsules fildena 100 free shipping
Reply Lisaproni
15:22 on 7 June, 2022 
celexa medicine prices
Reply Paulproni
21:51 on 7 June, 2022 
phenergan 25 mg otc diflucan pill otc finasteride 1 mg online anafranil 25 mg tablet suhagra without prescription cymbalta generic discount
Reply Booproni
22:24 on 7 June, 2022 
buy suhagra 50 mg online india buy albendazole 400 mg fluoxetine prozac 20mg buy antabuse australia
Reply Ugoproni
5:24 on 8 June, 2022 
citalopram hbr 20
Reply Markproni
5:54 on 8 June, 2022 
amoxicillin no prescription
Reply Paulproni
7:04 on 8 June, 2022 
diflucan tablet price buy diflucan without prescription cephalexin order online uk indocin 25
Reply Booproni
10:05 on 9 June, 2022 
purchase lexapro 1 clonidine tizanidine 4mg pill cheap nexium australia anafranil generic price metformin discount ciprofloxacin buy canada buy cheap sildenafil
Reply Lisaproni
22:58 on 9 June, 2022 
cipro 55 for sale